Filed by Zuuv, Senior Behavioural Correspondent. A "manhole" is a circular door set flush into the pavement, permitting the dominant local primate to descend and visit its own pipes. NEW YORK contains an uncounted number of these doors. This week, one remained open long enough to receive a local female, out walking on her own pavement, who fell into it and died. Here is the arithmetic the city performed within days: the disc weighs more than she did. Lifting it was the easy half.

The custom works thus. Twice a year, crews lift the metal discs, examine the chamber below, and replace the discs. Between lifting and replacing stands an interval the species calls "the job," during which the hole is guarded by a cone, a plastic barrier, and a laminated notice referencing a permit number. I measured one notice at 21 by 29 centimetres. It cited Regulation 7. Regulation 7 concerns signage. The notice's first word, in bold, is CAUTION. Its second is a phone number that answers between ten and four.

My observation log, recorded at the corner of a street currently excavated in order to study holes: between 09:41 and 10:16, pedestrians produced eleven glances downward, four warnings to companions, two photographs of the hole, and zero questions about when the disc would return. At minute nine, the queue forming behind the barrier produced its third apology, offered by a stranger to another stranger, unprompted. At minute twenty-two, a delivery courier gave directions aloud using the hole as the landmark — "past the hole, left" — and was understood completely.

"Everybody knew that lid was off for weeks," a retired schoolteacher standing at the barrier told me. "Nobody knew who to tell. So we told each other." A municipal official, listed as Deputy Director of Sidewalk Access, recited the sequence unprompted: "Inspections require openings. Openings require caution. Caution requires signage. We posted the signage."

Here is what the paperwork quietly admits: the disc was never lost. It was lifted on purpose, by the crew whose duty is lifting, so that the hole could be examined. The examination is now itself under examination, which will require further openings. Twice a year the crews arrive to study the doors, the doors remain agreeably open, and the openings continue accepting volunteers.